Precautionary allergen labelling in the UK: a guide to 'may contain' warnings


Walk down any UK supermarket aisle and you will quickly spot phrases like "May contain nuts" or "Not suitable for milk allergy sufferers". Known formally as precautionary allergen labelling (PAL), these warnings exist to alert shoppers to the risk of unintended allergen cross-contact during farming, transport, storage or manufacturing.
Yet for millions of people living with food hypersensitivities (and the businesses feeding them), these labels have long been a source of frustration. Because the rules governing when and how warnings are applied lack strict standardisation, shoppers are often left guessing whether a label flags a genuine, life-threatening hazard or a cautious legal disclaimer.
With global food safety bodies and the UK's Food Standards Agency (FSA) actively working to bring clearer science to these warnings, here is what both UK consumers and food businesses need to know right now.
If you manage a food allergy or coeliac disease in the UK, understanding what sits behind a "may contain" warning is vital for keeping yourself safe without unnecessarily restricting your diet.
Under current UK law, food businesses must legally highlight the 14 major allergens (such as peanuts, milk, eggs and gluten-containing cereals) in the ingredients list whenever they are intentionally used in a recipe. However, PAL covers unintentional traces, and using it is voluntary. Because manufacturers use different methods to assess risk, two similar packets of biscuits sitting side by side might carry completely different warnings, or none at all, despite being made in similar factories using similar manufacturing processes.
When businesses slap generic warnings onto products "just in case", two unhelpful things happen:
Fewer choices at the checkout: People with allergies end up avoiding foods that are actually safe for them, shrinking their dietary options and often forcing them to buy pricier alternatives.
Risky guesswork: Overwhelmed by warnings on almost everything, some shoppers experience "warning fatigue" and start ignoring labels altogether. That is a dangerous gamble when a genuine cross-contact risk is present.
A common misconception among UK shoppers is that a vegan label guarantees a product is free from milk or egg traces. Under FSA guidance, PAL can legally be used alongside a vegan or vegetarian label. Vegan labelling communicates dietary ethics rather than medical safety, meaning a vegan biscuit can still carry a "May contain milk" warning if it is made on shared equipment.
Unlike vegan claims, "free-from" claims (such as dairy-free or gluten-free) are strict guarantees of safety. Under FSA rules, a business cannot combine a free-from claim with a PAL statement for the exact same allergen. For example, a product cannot say "Free-from milk" and "May contain milk". If you have a severe allergy, seeking out certified free-from products remains your safest bet.
In 2026, the international food standards body Codex Alimentarius adopted new global guidelines to standardise PAL, a move closely backed by the FSA for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Under this framework, warnings are tied to science-based allergen thresholds (specifically the ED05 level). This is the tiny amount of allergenic protein predicted to trigger mild-to-moderate symptoms in 5% of sensitive people, with clinical evidence showing no severe reactions below this level.
As these principles take root across the industry, the goal is that the absence of a warning will reliably tell you that a product has passed a rigorous, scientific risk assessment, rather than the manufacturer simply skipping the check.
For UK manufacturers, caterers and retailers, PAL is never a shortcut around good food hygiene. Misusing it erodes customer trust and can put your business on the wrong side of UK food law.
FSA guidance is clear: PAL must only be used as a last resort. Before considering a warning label, you must put strict allergen management controls in place, including dedicated equipment, validated cleaning routines, thorough staff training and supplier audits. Applying a "may contain" label without conducting a genuine risk assessment can be deemed misleading to consumers and a breach of food safety regulations.
You should only apply PAL when a formal risk assessment identifies a real, unavoidable risk of cross-contact in your supply chain or kitchen. Your assessment should cover:
Incoming ingredients: Review supplier specifications and pass on any upstream PAL warnings to your customers unless your own risk assessment proves the risk has been eliminated.
On-site cross-contact points: Map every stage of storage, preparation and packaging where airborne dust, shared utensils or line changeovers could transfer trace proteins.
Change management: Re-evaluate your PAL immediately whenever you switch an ingredient supplier, tweak a recipe or alter production equipment.
Vague blanket statements like "May contain allergens" or "Made in a factory that handles nuts" are unhelpful and discouraged by the FSA.
Name the exact allergen: State "May contain peanuts and hazelnuts" rather than a generic "May contain nuts".
Use plain phrasing: Stick to straightforward, FSA-recommended wording such as "May contain [X]" or "Not suitable for consumers with a [X] allergy".
Remember loose food rules: If you run a café, bakery or restaurant selling non-prepacked food, PAL does not have to be printed on a wrapper, but it must still be clearly communicated via visible signage or well-informed staff.
With the Codex Alimentarius guidelines establishing international reference doses, and the FSA supporting greater standardisation, quantitative risk assessment is fast becoming the industry benchmark.
Businesses should start moving away from guesswork and towards quantitative risk modelling. By measuring potential cross-contact against portion sizes and validated reference doses, you can make scientifically defensible decisions. Applying PAL only when trace levels exceed safe thresholds will give UK shoppers back the confidence they need to trust your labels.
Do treat PAL as a final step only after physical controls and cleaning cannot eliminate cross-contact.
Do specify the exact tree nut, cereal or other allergen at risk.
Don't put a PAL warning and a "free-from" claim on the same product for the same allergen.
Don't use blanket disclaimers to cover poor allergen management practices.
Build confidence in allergen safety with The Safer Food Group
Whether you are looking to protect your customers or simply want a clearer understanding of UK food safety rules, the right knowledge makes all the difference. Explore The Safer Food Group's accredited Food Allergen Awareness training courses and practical compliance resources to stay up to date with Food Standards Agency guidance and keep your kitchen, business or family safe.
Walk down any UK supermarket aisle and you will quickly spot phrases like "May contain nuts" or "Not suitable for milk allergy sufferers". Known formally as precautionary allergen labelling (PAL), these warnings exist to alert shoppers to the risk of unintended allergen cross-contact during farming, transport, storage or manufacturing.
Yet for millions of people living with food hypersensitivities (and the businesses feeding them), these labels have long been a source of frustration. Because the rules governing when and how warnings are applied lack strict standardisation, shoppers are often left guessing whether a label flags a genuine, life-threatening hazard or a cautious legal disclaimer.
With global food safety bodies and the UK's Food Standards Agency (FSA) actively working to bring clearer science to these warnings, here is what both UK consumers and food businesses need to know right now.
If you manage a food allergy or coeliac disease in the UK, understanding what sits behind a "may contain" warning is vital for keeping yourself safe without unnecessarily restricting your diet.
Under current UK law, food businesses must legally highlight the 14 major allergens (such as peanuts, milk, eggs and gluten-containing cereals) in the ingredients list whenever they are intentionally used in a recipe. However, PAL covers unintentional traces, and using it is voluntary. Because manufacturers use different methods to assess risk, two similar packets of biscuits sitting side by side might carry completely different warnings, or none at all, despite being made in similar factories using similar manufacturing processes.
When businesses slap generic warnings onto products "just in case", two unhelpful things happen:
Fewer choices at the checkout: People with allergies end up avoiding foods that are actually safe for them, shrinking their dietary options and often forcing them to buy pricier alternatives.
Risky guesswork: Overwhelmed by warnings on almost everything, some shoppers experience "warning fatigue" and start ignoring labels altogether. That is a dangerous gamble when a genuine cross-contact risk is present.
A common misconception among UK shoppers is that a vegan label guarantees a product is free from milk or egg traces. Under FSA guidance, PAL can legally be used alongside a vegan or vegetarian label. Vegan labelling communicates dietary ethics rather than medical safety, meaning a vegan biscuit can still carry a "May contain milk" warning if it is made on shared equipment.
Unlike vegan claims, "free-from" claims (such as dairy-free or gluten-free) are strict guarantees of safety. Under FSA rules, a business cannot combine a free-from claim with a PAL statement for the exact same allergen. For example, a product cannot say "Free-from milk" and "May contain milk". If you have a severe allergy, seeking out certified free-from products remains your safest bet.
In 2026, the international food standards body Codex Alimentarius adopted new global guidelines to standardise PAL, a move closely backed by the FSA for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Under this framework, warnings are tied to science-based allergen thresholds (specifically the ED05 level). This is the tiny amount of allergenic protein predicted to trigger mild-to-moderate symptoms in 5% of sensitive people, with clinical evidence showing no severe reactions below this level.
As these principles take root across the industry, the goal is that the absence of a warning will reliably tell you that a product has passed a rigorous, scientific risk assessment, rather than the manufacturer simply skipping the check.
For UK manufacturers, caterers and retailers, PAL is never a shortcut around good food hygiene. Misusing it erodes customer trust and can put your business on the wrong side of UK food law.
FSA guidance is clear: PAL must only be used as a last resort. Before considering a warning label, you must put strict allergen management controls in place, including dedicated equipment, validated cleaning routines, thorough staff training and supplier audits. Applying a "may contain" label without conducting a genuine risk assessment can be deemed misleading to consumers and a breach of food safety regulations.
You should only apply PAL when a formal risk assessment identifies a real, unavoidable risk of cross-contact in your supply chain or kitchen. Your assessment should cover:
Incoming ingredients: Review supplier specifications and pass on any upstream PAL warnings to your customers unless your own risk assessment proves the risk has been eliminated.
On-site cross-contact points: Map every stage of storage, preparation and packaging where airborne dust, shared utensils or line changeovers could transfer trace proteins.
Change management: Re-evaluate your PAL immediately whenever you switch an ingredient supplier, tweak a recipe or alter production equipment.
Vague blanket statements like "May contain allergens" or "Made in a factory that handles nuts" are unhelpful and discouraged by the FSA.
Name the exact allergen: State "May contain peanuts and hazelnuts" rather than a generic "May contain nuts".
Use plain phrasing: Stick to straightforward, FSA-recommended wording such as "May contain [X]" or "Not suitable for consumers with a [X] allergy".
Remember loose food rules: If you run a café, bakery or restaurant selling non-prepacked food, PAL does not have to be printed on a wrapper, but it must still be clearly communicated via visible signage or well-informed staff.
With the Codex Alimentarius guidelines establishing international reference doses, and the FSA supporting greater standardisation, quantitative risk assessment is fast becoming the industry benchmark.
Businesses should start moving away from guesswork and towards quantitative risk modelling. By measuring potential cross-contact against portion sizes and validated reference doses, you can make scientifically defensible decisions. Applying PAL only when trace levels exceed safe thresholds will give UK shoppers back the confidence they need to trust your labels.
Do treat PAL as a final step only after physical controls and cleaning cannot eliminate cross-contact.
Do specify the exact tree nut, cereal or other allergen at risk.
Don't put a PAL warning and a "free-from" claim on the same product for the same allergen.
Don't use blanket disclaimers to cover poor allergen management practices.
Build confidence in allergen safety with The Safer Food Group
Whether you are looking to protect your customers or simply want a clearer understanding of UK food safety rules, the right knowledge makes all the difference. Explore The Safer Food Group's accredited Food Allergen Awareness training courses and practical compliance resources to stay up to date with Food Standards Agency guidance and keep your kitchen, business or family safe.
Join 950,000+ learners
Explore our award winning online video based training
The Safer Food Group
Unit 2, Integrity House,
Lower Lumsdale, Matlock
DE4 5EX
Back
to top
© The Safer Food Group 2026 | Privacy policy